Columbus Crew vs New York City FC

The MLS is where reputations are built and defended — and on Wednesday, matchday 1 at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field will add another chapter to that story. Columbus Crew (.) won their last game 2 - 0 against Atlanta United FC — a result that left them in confident mood heading into this top-flight encounter. New York City FC (.) have scored goals this season and lost 2 - 1 against Nashville S.C. last time out. In the last 6 months, they have won 5 of their 15 fixtures. Our model weighs every factor and arrives at a 39% probability for Columbus Crew to come out on top and cement their standing in the MLS.

Betting Tips and Odds for Columbus Crew vs New York City FC – All in One Place

Three-Way BetColumbus Crew39%32/33·PalmslotsT&C's apply | +18 Total Goals Over/Under 2.5Under 2.5 Goals54%6/5·PalmslotsT&C's apply | +18 ★ Expert TipExpert TipUnder 2.5 Goals54%6/5·PalmslotsT&C's apply | +18

Statistical prediction with probability factor

Three-Way BetColumbus Crew 39% · X 27% · New York City FC 34%Columbus CrewXNew York City FCBoth Teams To Score Yes/NoYes 51% · No 49%YesNoTotal Goals Over/Under 2.5Over 46% · Under 54%OverUnderTotal Goals Over/Under 3.5Over 24% · Under 76%OverUnderCorrect Score1-113%1-011%0-110%

Who will win Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

Submit your tip and see how others have voted.

Current odds for Columbus Crew vs New York City FC

ProbabilityColumbus Crew39%Draw27%New York City FC34%

10/1114/512/5Odd last updated:

10/1113/513/5Odd last updated:

32/3327/1012/5Odd last updated:

Form Analysis and Performance Comparison

Columbus Crew Form

Last 5 games

WDLLL

Columbus Crew most recently faced Atlanta United FC, winning the match 2 - 0. It was a result that left the squad in confident mood ahead of this next challenge.

The last 6 months have seen Columbus Crew play 15 competitive matches, winning 4 and losing 7. Of their 7 home games during this stretch, they have won 3 and lost 2. They have scored 21 goals at home and away combined, conceding 23.

Columbus Crew's most recent 15 games tell an interesting story. They have scored 21 goals (1.4 per game) while conceding 23 (1.53 per game). In terms of home performances, Columbus Crew have won 3, drawn 2 and lost 2 of their 7 home matches – a record that provides useful context ahead of this fixture.

New York City FC Form

Last 5 games

LDWWL

New York City FC most recently faced Nashville S.C., losing the match 2 - 1. It was a result that left the squad determined to bounce back and take something from this trip to ScottsMiracle-Gro Field.

Over the past 6 months, New York City FC have won 5, drawn 4 and lost 6 of their 15 games. Away from home they have picked up 2 wins from 7 fixtures, losing 3. They have scored 25 goals in total during this period – an average of 1.67 per game.

New York City FC's most recent 15 games tell an interesting story. They have scored 25 goals (1.67 per game) while conceding 21 (1.4 per game). In terms of away performances specifically, New York City FC have won 2, drawn 2 and lost 3 of their 7 away matches — a record that provides useful context ahead of this trip to ScottsMiracle-Gro Field.

Stats per Game

Columbus Crew New York City FC

Goals scored

1.6

1.2

Corners

4.8

2.8

Fouls

Saves

1.9

3.6

MLS

MLS Table

#	Team	Played	Diff.	Pnts
1	Nashville S.C.	14	20	33
2	Inter Miami CF	15	11	31
3	Chicago Fire FC	14	11	26
· · · 3 places · · ·
7	FC Cincinnati	15	-1	20
8	New York City FC Away	15	4	19
9	D.C. United	15	-4	18
10	Columbus Crew Home	15	-2	16
11	CF Montréal	14	-9	14

Last Meetings

05/20/2026

Columbus Crew
New York City FC

1-0

05/10/2026

New York City FC
Columbus Crew

3-0

03/22/2025

Columbus Crew
New York City FC

0-0

08/31/2024

Columbus Crew
New York City FC

4-2

Form Trend – Points per Game (Last 5 Matches)

■ Columbus Crew ■ New York City FC

Our AI Betting Tip for Columbus Crew vs New York City FC

After weighing up all available data for Columbus Crew vs New York City FC, our AI model favours Columbus Crew to win on home soil at a probability of 39%. The best odds for this outcome are 32/33 at Palmslots. Our standout tip is "Total Goals Over/Under 2.5" — a 54% probability with top odds of 6/5 at Palmslots.Best Tip Under 2.5 Goals6/5Place betT&C's apply | +18